The Gospel of Gotcha

« Irrefutable Lessons in the Theology of Geography

Designer God – Some Assembly Required »

The Gospel of Gotcha

Saturday, March 16th, 2013 by Lori Roeleveld One Comment

My kid brother enjoyed torturing me.

It wasn’t hard to do.

Two of his favorite methods of torture

were to hide places in the house and jump out at me as I walked past

(I was a nervous kid right out of the gate)

or sneak up to the windows after school and try to catch me

singing into my hairbrush performing imaginary concerts in the living room.

I kept a vigilant eye out for him all the time

but he got the best of me more often than I was able to ferret him out.

“Gotcha!” His triumphant cry

and no matter how much my mother scolded him

she couldn’t change the humiliating fact that I’d been “got.”

“Outed” in my skittish fearfulness.

“Busted” in my fantastical imaginary life where I was a famous singer performing for millions.

What is it that makes us do that to one another?

Because it’s not just my brother,

something in all of us revels in catching others, particularly those we envy, in some weakness or failing.

I’ll admit that when I find someone intimidating or whose life seems more perfect than mine,

I can easily be tempted to comfort myself with their failings, real or imagined, so that I can somehow

excuse myself from trying harder or applying myself to change.

We live in a “gotcha” culture of media aggressively seeking the next big expose

and crime shows designed to train us all as profilers and vigilante detectives.

In the church, we use theological sounding words to cover our inner reveling at the “gotcha” of others,

we hijack concepts like accountability, tough love, confrontation, cleansing, and discipline to mean

something other

than the constructive tools these ideas are when administered with truth, love, grace, and in the context of the gospel that we have ALL fallen short.

We are so tuned to the “gotcha” gospel, that the most shocking moment in our lives is the exercise of grace,

even with 2000 years of church history behind us –

unmerited forgiveness and kindness extended to sinners

remains a rarity so remarkable our hearts and minds scramble to grasp the magnitude of it

but we often fail to penetrate its mystery and bounce off of grace like hailstones on a tin roof

landing far from grace

dazed and confused

because we know that of all spiritual disciplines,

extending grace is the thing for which we most need the power of the Holy Spirit

it is the thing we are least likely to be able to pull off under our own steam.

So when a writer pens a scene in a novel in 1862,

a scene of grace extended to a convict,

a man who repays the hospitality of a priest by robbing him

and then the priest acts out the gospel of grace

in the face of the gospel of gotcha

this scene endures through the centuries

as one we never tire of watching, of portraying, of retelling

at the wonder of it.

When Bishop Myriel hands Jean Valjean the candlesticks to add to his pilfered bag of treasure

he hands us the gospel on a silver platter

and we squirm at the discomfort of something so foreign

we know it must be supernatural.

Are you living out the gospel of “gotcha” or the gospel of grace?

The first, can be accomplished under our own steam,

the second requires a power source that can only be found at the feet of Jesus.

Do you have a story of grace extended to you or to another that you’ve witnessed? It would bring joy to all of us to hear it here today.

1 Comment

The Conversation

Don Umphrey says:

March 16, 2013 at 6:09 pm

The Gospel of Political Correctness feasts on “gotcha” media moments. A slum lord goes unnoticed while a person seeking to do the right thing accidentally uses the wrong word or phrase and is depicted being worthy of crucifixion.

Reply